News

Opinion: The Most Ridiculous, Wasteful Food Recall of 2024

Between a deadly E. coli outbreak at McDonald’s and salmonella-contaminated cucumbers that sickened hundreds, 2024 has been a year of many food recalls. One recall, though, takes the cake as the most ridiculous and wasteful.

Earlier this year, government authorities forced Costco to recall over 80,000 pounds of its Kirkland butter.
Was the butter contaminated with some deadly pathogen or otherwise unfit for human consumption?

No. Costco’s “crime” was to mistakenly forget to add to the butter’s packaging that it contains milk.

Technically, because milk is a human allergen, this put the butter in violation of FDA labeling requirements. The FDA and USDA thus forced Costco to recall and destroy multiple tons of butter.

Close-up of signs listing prices at Costco food court, including the price for Costco’s hot dog and fountain soda combination, Danville, California, July 3, 2022.

Now, for some kinds of recalls, these requirements make perfect sense.

If a food is mistakenly manufactured with peanuts in it and the company fails to disclose that on the label, someone could eat the food, go into shock, and end up in the hospital or worse. It’s totally reasonable to recall foods with these kinds of undeclared allergens.

In the case of Costco’s butter, though, the fact that butter contains milk products should be completely obvious to anyone who understands what butter is.

Butter is derived from milk. Of course, it contains milk allergens!

Forcing the company to label butter as containing milk would be a bit akin to forcing a label that says “rain contains water” or that peanut butter contains peanuts. It’s abundantly obvious from the product itself.

In this case, many tons of butter were needlessly wasted over a simple printing error.

One wonders whether the FDA could have simply had Costco print a sign stating that the butter contains milk and display this on the case where the butter was sold. Wouldn’t that be enough to clue in any consumer who didn’t understand cows well enough to know where butter comes from?

Again, it’s necessary to step in for things like E. coli-contaminated onions or salmonella-infected cucumbers. But when a simple and obvious printing error results in such an impactful recall, it goes from useful to simply wasteful.

Thomas Smith

Thomas Smith is a food and travel photographer and writer based in the San Francisco Bay Area. His photographic work routinely appears in publications including Food and Wine, Conde Nast Traveler, and the New York Times and his writing appears in IEEE Spectrum, SFGate, the Bold Italic and more. Smith holds a degree in Cognitive Science (Neuroscience) and Anthropology from the Johns Hopkins University.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button